In the gripping world of Red Dead Redemption 2, the mission “Fatherhood and Other Dreams” unfolds as a poignant tale of love, family, and redemption. This optional honor story mission, set in the vibrant city of Saint Denis, follows Arthur Morgan as he reconnects with his past love, Mary Linton, and embarks on a quest to reclaim a treasured family heirloom. Dive into our comprehensive walkthrough to navigate the intricate narrative and challenges of this mission, ensuring you secure the coveted Lending a Hand trophy and maximize your honor points.
As a reminder, the first meeting with Mary took place in the second chapter of the game as part of the task of completing the mission We Loved Once and True. As in the previous mission, you must wait until Arthur receives a letter from Mary. You will be informed that the letter has been delivered and it will be visible on the camp map. The letter should reach Arthur in the fourth chapter of the game.
Go to the wetland camp and enter the main building. The letter should lie on a world map in a room on the first floor, next to Arthur’s bed.
On the map of Saint Denis,you will see a marker indicating Mary. Go there – you have to reach Hotel Grand, then, a cut-scene will commence. Confirm that you want to help her.
Together with Mary, set off to the stable near the Saint Denis railway tracks. After reaching the stable, let Mary go inside alone and watch another cut-scene.
Once you regain control of Arthur, you must follow Mary’s father. Keep a safe distance from him. A drunken man will fortunately walk slowly. You don’t have to speed up when he disappears for a moment around the corner. Ultimately, you need to reach the place where he sells the brooch to the trader.
Arthur must set out to chase the merchant in order to recover the brooch, which is a family souvenir. Start to run after the man, and after a while you have to steal the horse, because the man will jump into the stagecoach. Follow him and do nothing else until you leave Saint Denis. Only then approach the stagecoach close enough to be able to jump on it from the horse.
Swing the analog knob towards the coachman and let Arthur get closer to him in order to throw him off the carriage. Once you’ve taken control of the stagecoach, set off to a marked, isolated place.
Stop the stagecoach in the wetlands and throw the merchant out. You can scare the man and pay him $100 (positive honor points) or beat him (negative honor points). In both cases you will get beck Mary’s Brooch.
What makes the “Fatherhood and Other Dreams” mission unique compared to other Red Dead Redemption 2 missions
The “Fatherhood and Other Dreams” mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 stands out for several reasons:
-
Emotional Connection: This mission offers a deep dive into Arthur Morgan’s past, particularly his relationship with Mary Linton, providing insight into his emotional life and personal struggles.
-
Optional Honor Story Mission: It is an optional mission that contributes to the Lending a Hand trophy, making it significant for players aiming to complete all honor-related achievements.
-
Unique Gameplay Mechanics: The mission involves following a character through the streets, a high-speed chase, and a choice to either buy back or forcefully retrieve a family heirloom, offering varied gameplay experiences.
-
Cultural Engagement: The mission concludes with a visit to the theater, where Arthur and Mary watch a performance, adding a cultural and social element to the game’s narrative.
What makes the dynamic between Arthur and Mary so compelling
The dynamic between Arthur Morgan and Mary Linton in Red Dead Redemption 2 is compelling for several reasons:
-
Emotional Depth: Arthur’s relationship with Mary is deeply rooted in his past, showcasing a profound emotional connection. His lingering feelings for her are a significant part of his character development, highlighting themes of love, regret, and longing1.
-
Narrative Complexity: Mary’s character serves as a catalyst for Arthur’s emotional turmoil. Her actions, particularly her decision to leave him despite his efforts to help her family, evoke sympathy for Arthur and underscore his tragic fate.
-
Contrast to Other Relationships: Unlike his platonic bond with Sadie Adler, Arthur’s connection with Mary is romantic and nostalgic. This contrast adds depth to Arthur’s character, showing his capacity for love and heartbreak1.
-
Storyline Impact: The missions involving Mary, such as “Fatherhood and Other Dreams,” provide pivotal moments in Arthur’s story, influencing his honor and character development throughout the game.
